Airbnb vs. Long-Term Rentals: Which is Better for Your Los Cabos Property?

If you own a property in Cabo San Lucas or are considering investing, one of your biggest decisions will be choosing between short-term vacation rentals (Airbnb/VRBO/ETC) and long-term traditional leases. Each model has unique advantages, challenges, and hidden costs.

In this guide, we’ll break down:
✔ Key differences between Short-term rentals and long-term rentals in Los Cabos
✔ Pros and cons of each strategy
✔ Management and maintenance costs
✔ Marketing strategies for each model
✔ Which generates higher profits? (Including real market data)

1. Key Differences: Airbnb vs. Long-Term Rentals in Los Cabos

---

2. Pros and Cons of Each Rental Strategy

🔹 Plataforms & Short-Term Rentals

 Advantages:

• Higher peak-season income: A well-located Los Cabos property can earn 2-3x more than long-term rentals in winter.

• Flexibility: Block dates for personal use.

• Diverse clientele: Attract international tourists.

Disadvantages:

• High operational costs: Cleaning fees, platform commissions (15-20%), maintenance.

• Seasonal instability: Lower occupancy in Sept-Nov (hurricane season).

• Time-intensive: Guest communication, check-ins, urgent repairs.

🔹 Long-Term Rentals

 Advantages:

• Steady cash flow: A 1-year lease guarantees fixed monthly income.

• Less wear & tear: Fewer turnovers mean lower maintenance.

• Passive management: No daily guest interactions.

 Disadvantages:

• Lower profitability: Earns 40-60% less than Airbnb in tourist zones.

• Problem tenants risk: Late payments or evictions.

• No personal use: Property is occupied year-round.

3. Management & Maintenance Costs

 Airbnb (Short-Term Rental)

• Cleaning fees: $50-$300USD per stay (varies by property size).

• Maintenance: General home and equipment maintenance, including air conditioning, pool, plumbing, carpentry, painting, etc.

• 
  Platform fees: 15-20% per booking.

• Additional services: High-speed WiFi, toiletries, pool maintenance.

• Marketing: Professional photos ($200-$500USD), Airbnb SEO, paid ads.

 Long-Term Rental

• Basic maintenance: Occasional repairs, repainting every 2-3 years.

• Lease management: Lawyer/agent fee (1 month’s rent).

• Rental insurance: Covers damages or unpaid rent.

4. Marketing Strategies for Each Model

 Airbnb (Targeting Tourists)

• Professional photos: Essential for high booking rates.

• SEO optimization: Use keywords like “luxury Cabo villa near beach” or “family-friendly vacation rental.”

• Dynamic pricing: Tools like PriceLabs adjust rates based on demand.

• Unique experiences: Offer “private yacht add-ons” to boost appeal.

 Long-Term Rentals (Targeting Expats/Residents)

• Real estate platforms: List on Vivanuncios, Trovit, Facebook.

• Corporate partnerships: Lease to expats working at local resorts.

• Flexible leases: 6-month terms for temporary workers.

5. Which Generates More Income in Los Cabos?

Absolutely short-term rentals, however this will largely depend on capacity and demand during the holiday season.

💡 Conclusion: If you want maximum profitability and can handle operations, Airbnb wins. If you prefer low-effort stability, choose long-term rentals.

6. Hybrid Strategy: The Best of Both Worlds?

Some owners combine both models:

• Long-term tenants in low season (Sept-Nov).

• Switch to Airbnb in peak season (Dec-Apr).

⚠ Key requirement: A flexible lease agreement.

 Final Verdict: Which Should You Choose?

• Pick Airbnb if: You want higher returns, have management support, and your property is in a tourist hotspot.

• Pick long-term if: You prioritize hassle-free, steady income.

Need Help Managing Your Cabo Property?

At Cabo Estate Management, we specialize in maximizing returns for short-term and long-term rentals. Get a free consultation!

📞 Phone: +52 624-159-3843
📧 Email: Caboestatemgmt@gmail.com